Press Release

ARE YOU A MORAL PLANNER OR A MUDDLER?


Mr. Micawber trod a fine line between happiness and disaster. But his delicate balancing act between income and expenditure was only one approach to bill paying. Today, researchers reveal the other four.

Money Matters by Claire Whyley, Elaine Kempson and Alicia Herbert, published today by the Policy Studies Institute, identifies the five different types of money manager:

  • The 'Moral Planners' are the strictest money managers of all, seeing it as their moral duty to pay bills promptly. They manage money methodically and tend to use cheques or cash, giving them greater control. The great majority of Moral Planners are pensioners, usually women, with fixed incomes and low outgoings. They value their independence, fear debt and express a strong desire to keep their affairs in order as they approach the end of their lives. They would rather go without than fall behind with their bills and their approach to money can be summed up with the thought that if you can t afford it, don t have it. Moral Planners would no more delay paying a bill than they would try to leave a shop without paying.

  • 'Pragmatic Planners' also have a rigorous and systematic approach to money management, although this is for convenience rather than moral duty. Often they are women, between their late 20s and early 50s, living busy working lives . Both they and their partners are in full-time work they are unlikely to have dependent children. Their incomes are high enough for money not to be a problem and they set up direct debits and standing orders or make annual payments to save money. They don t have the time to take a close interest in bills and pay promptly to secure peace of mind.

  • By contrast, 'Flexible Planners' tend to have a more relaxed approach to money and to be more reactive than planned. They are both men and women of a similar age to the Pragmatic Planners but earn less and spend more. They use a range of ways to pay bills which give them flexibility and they juggle payments when the need arises. Flexible Planners often try to save but rarely manage to put aside as much as they need or end up spending the money on something else instead. They are less experienced as money managers and their expenses can be difficult to predict. Their approach can be summed up with the idea: You never know what's round the corner. Some Flexible Planners delay payments on principle to stop creditors accruing interest or to protest against poor service or rising prices.

  • The 'Muddlers' do not manage their money at all - neither planning ahead or keeping a record of spending. They have no idea what their expenses are or when their bills are due and often lose bills, forget about them or pay them late. The Muddlers divide into two groups. The first includes those forced into this approach by a change in circumstances (such as the breakdown of a relationship or the birth of a child) who try to put off the evil day when bills are due. The second include those who have never been able to manage their money and who say it just sort of happens as well as those for whom bill paying is not a high priority.

  • The final group operate a 'Pay As You Go' system, paying for things frequently and in small amounts. They tend to shop daily and meet most of their bills through direct deductions from benefit, pre-payment meters or savings stamps. Usually these methods are imposed by creditors. Typically members of this group are unemployed or on low incomes and face a constant struggle to make ends meet.

The authors draw out the lessons for creditors. They suggest that there are ways to encourage both those who can afford it and those who are poor money managers to pay more promptly. Deliberate late payers, for example, could be offered incentives or persuaded to pay by a brisk but fair approach to arrears recovery. Muddlers might be encouraged by promoting the use of frequent payment and pay-as-you-go options.

'The way people manage their money is not entirely due to their individual personality' says Claire Whyley. 'People move from one system to another as their personal and financial circumstances change. As people get older and have more experience of money management and more stable circumstances, for example, they adopt a more careful and better planned approach to their finances. And major life changes such as the death of a partner, redundancy or the birth of a baby can force people to adopt a more flexible manner of bill paying.'

'There is a delicate balancing act to tread between encouraging recalcitrant payers to pay up and supporting people in genuine hardship to spread the cost of bills' says Elaine Kempson. 'Companies need to contact persistent late payers to distinguish those who cannot pay from those who have the money but are delaying payment. This will require a more sophisticated system of information.'

ENDS


Contact: Neil Churchill on 0171 468 2236 (Monday to Friday during office hours)
0374 756 920 (Outside office hours or on Saturday 12th)

Notes to Editors:
  1. Money Matters is available from Grantham Books on 01476 541 080, priced £10.95.

  2. PSI is a registered educational charity (no 313819) and has no association with any political party, pressure group or commercial interest.

Press Release Index Research Index Publications Home Page